Document storing and sharing - choosing the right solution


OVERVIEW

Target audience: McGill staff, faculty and students

Several options for document storing and sharing are presently available to the McGill community. The comparison chart below can help you select the most appropriate solution for your needs.

IMPORTANT: New OneDrive storage capacity starting May 31st 2024

On May 31st, 2024, OneDrive storage capacity for all students, will be adjusted to 20GB, to comply with Microsoft’s new Storage quota for its educational sector clients.

If you are a McGill student, please verify your current storage using the instructions in this article: How to check file storage usage in OneDrive.

If your current storage exceeds 20GB, empty the recycle bin, remove shared items and application installers. Move older, unused files and large files such as videos, PowerPoint presentations or picture libraries, off your OneDrive, to another location right away so you are ready for May 31st storage space reduction.

The OneDrive storage provided to staff or faculty members will not be affected.

More details about this initiative can be found in this announcement on the ITS website.

Supported document storing and sharing solutions

Solution

Who can use it

Primary purpose

Hosting and backups

Main characteristics / benefits

Use Cases

OneDrive

McGill staff (including affiliates), faculty and students who have access to the Office 365 portal.

Store work, research and documents related to current studies.

Documents that are being worked on, on a day-to-day basis.

Cloud storage, backed up by Microsoft

Students are allotted 20GB of OneDrive storage. 

Full restore to a state within 30 days

Deleted documents recoverable up to 93 days from the recycling bin

Local synchronization on your computer

Access files from anywhere on any device via secure Azure AD Login

No VPN required outside McGill network

Integration with other Microsoft 365 apps

Version History

Individual manages sharing, permissions, organization, etc.

Easy external and internal sharing

Draft and work versions of  documents.

Meeting recordings (from Teams)

Personal information and documents should not be stored on OneDrive for extended periods.

Microsoft Teams

McGill staff (including affiliates), faculty and students who have access to the Microsoft 365 portal

Collaborate on an integrated team hub, with quick & easy access to files; hold conversations, work together in files, call and meet

Cloud storage, backed up by Microsoft

Large storage, up to 25TB per site

Full restore to a state within 30 days

Deleted documents recoverable up to 93 days from the recycling bin

Integration with other Microsoft 365 apps

Chat enabled

Easy to use, collaborate and share

Easy external and internal sharing

Team / site owner(s) manage membership permissions, organization

Local file synchronization on McGill-managed computer

Project or team working documents

Documents ready to be shared for committees: minutes of a meeting…

Research data (see specifics below)

SharePoint Site

McGill staff (including affiliates), faculty and students who have access to the Microsoft 365 portal

on request

Store and sync group work files in a central repository, without the need for chat, meetings, and other collaboration features of Teams. 

Advanced search capabilities by tagging files with keywords.

Documents libraries can be fully restored to a state within 30 days

Deleted documents recoverable up to 93 days from the recycling bin

Easy sharing with your team, members of the organization, and external users

Advanced permissions management

Site owner(s) manage membership permissions, organization

Integration with other Microsoft 365 apps

Local synchronization on your computer

Project or team working documents

Digital asset bank

Department Cloud Storage

Research data (see specifics below)

Documents ready to be shared with a team

D2 Spaces

* Not currently accepting new requests

McGill staff users with existing spaces

Store files on a limited Collaboration Space on private content 

 

Appropriate for final version or official record

On premises storage

Recoverable up to one year

Secure Azure AD login / No VPN required for access on Desktop/Laptop outside McGill network

Predictability with stable Interface

Custom Views

Managed by the user and IT

External and internal sharing available but not easy

Archived department data or projects

Network file storage

The recommended storage solution is now SharePoint.

McGill staff, faculty and student on request

Network file storage for personal use or department

Temporary /ad hoc solution for specific cases where there is very large number of documents.

 

On premises storage

Variable quota on the G:\ drive per unit/department

1GB for staff and faculty personal use on the R:\ drive

300MB for students with existing access

Recoverable up to one year

VPN required for access outside McGill network

Unlimited number of files per folder 

Besides the free departmental or unit/faculty folders, additional purchasable HNAS storage available if needed

Managed by IT Services

Server based applications

Whole department Shared Drive

Research Data (see specifics below)

Streaming Capability 

Personal and work files (especially files that cannot be stored on OneDrive / SharePoint)

 

Authorized data to be stored in each solution

Type of dataOn premises -
D2
On premises - Network File SharesCloud - McGill OneDriveCloud - McGill MS Teams /SharePoint
Regulated PI
(Personal Information)

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

Regulated – PHI
(Personal Health Information)
with Consent

Yes

No

No

Yes

Regulated PCI
(Payment Card Industry)

No

No

No

No

Regulated - Other

to be evaluated

to be evaluated

to be evaluated

to be evaluated

Protected

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

Public

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Customized services

If your requirement is not fulfilled by any of the above solutions, or if you need a customized interface, lifecycle, or workflows for your documents, reach out to the Collaboration Solution Team.

We may be able to customize existing tools to create a personalized application to address your needs.


references

ADDITIONAL REFERENCES: